The Curious Experience of Knowing

On intuition, perception, and the things we don’t understand

We seem to have collectively agreed that certain forms of knowing require little questioning, while others make us distinctly uncomfortable.

For instance, we readily accept being able to recognize a familiar voice in a crowded room, or to sense when someone is upset before they've said anything. Most of us are used to these small moments of recognition. It is, however, less acceptable for us to accurately sense when someone is upset while they are thousands of kilometers away, and we have no contact with them.

But sometimes information seems to arrive with such remarkable specificity that I find myself wondering why experiences of this kind remain so difficult to discuss, let alone investigate. I have been interested in this question for most of my life, although for a considerable portion of it, I decided to ignore it because it isolated me professionally.

Before there were words for it

As a child, I sometimes had very clear impressions about people I encountered. I could walk past someone in a grocery store, sit near a stranger, or meet a person briefly and become aware of what felt like a particular area of strain or vulnerability in their body. There was no deliberate observation involved, at least none that I could recognize. The impression simply emerged, sometimes with an almost physical quality of knowing.

I didn't have explanations for these experiences, and there wasn't much room for discussing them in the world I grew up in. Later, the demands of academic and professional life offered even less room.

So I put them aside. They had not disappeared, but other ways of knowing were more acceptable, and certainly easier to explain.

What music taught me about knowing

My training as a classical pianist involved decades of learning to perceive relationships that were not immediately obvious.

In the early years, much of my work was conscious and deliberate. There were notes to learn, movements to organize, structures to understand, technical problems to resolve. But gradually, perception began to change. I could hear and sense layers of relationships between sounds. I could sense where a phrase might deepen even when my hands couldn’t follow it, recognize a disruption in intensity before I could consciously identify it in the sound.

Of course, years of training and an enormous accumulation of experience were involved. They taught me something really important: conscious explanation is not always the beginning of understanding. In fact, it can arrive considerably later.

When knowing doesn't follow an obvious path

Over the years, as I began working extensively with somatic approaches, something of that earlier perceptual sensitivity deepened. And now, there was a framework within which I could work with it.

Somatic training gave me ways to observe movement, sensation, autonomic responses, energy flow, and nuanced changes in bodily organization. It also sometimes gave me reasons to question my own interpretations. Subtle impressions might be useful. They might be mistaken. They might arise from something I had noticed without consciously registering it. The impression itself could be clear while its meaning remained uncertain.

At times, when working with a client, vivid imagery appears in my awareness. At other times, it is a more immediate knowing: an age, a movement, a place, or some unexpectedly specific detail. Occasionally, a client independently describes something closely resembling what I had just perceived. These moments are particularly interesting to me, not least because they raise questions about how perception emerges between people.

What do we notice without knowing that we have noticed it? How much information is communicated through the body, voice, rhythm, relationship? What about experiences we describe as perceiving someone's energy field? What are the aspects of these experiences that our current explanations do not adequately settle?

I don't know, and I have become comfortable saying so.

What science can tell us

Intuition is not an unfamiliar subject in psychological and neuroscientific research. One understanding of intuition involves the use of information processed outside conscious awareness. We may arrive at a judgment or recognition before we can identify the elements that contributed to it.

Research has shown that information we are not consciously aware of can influence decisions. More recent theoretical work has explored intuition in relation to neural dynamics, experience, and how the brain organizes and anticipates information. These are fascinating areas of inquiry, because they suggest that some forms of knowing may involve processes that are considerably more complex than conscious awareness alone.

There is also another line of research concerned with what are called noetic experiences. The term refers to experiences characterized by a sense of direct knowing, sometimes without an identifiable source.

Researchers associated with the Institute of Noetic Sciences have developed an inventory describing different qualities of these experiences, including inner knowing, visual imagery, and embodied sensations. This research does not establish that people can access information through extraordinary means. It does, however, offer a vocabulary for investigating experiences that have often been difficult to describe.

I find both areas useful. One examines how perception and intuition may arise through processes outside conscious awareness. The other attempts to describe unusual experiences of knowing as they are reported by the people having them. Neither offers a complete explanation for what I encounter in my work, which makes the questions arising in my practice increasingly interesting.

The temptation to be right

Accurate intuition is highly seductive. I am easily tempted to assign it great significance, to treat it as evidence for an assumption, or to become more invested in being correct the next time.

This is where discipline and discernment have become particularly important. The sense of knowing is an experience. Whether the information is accurate is a separate question. A vivid image may feel compelling without corresponding to an external event. An impression may arise from subtle observations that I have not consciously registered. Remarkable correspondences are easily remembered.

In my own work, I stay attentive to these possibilities. I don't need a client to confirm what I perceive. Nor do I want my impressions to become the organizing principle of someone else's experience. I am definitely interested in what emerges when there is space for both of us to notice, especially when neither of us rushes toward interpretation. Without chasing premature conclusions, our experiences become increasingly layered and complex.

A little less certainty, perhaps

I wonder whether some of our discomfort with unusual forms of perception comes from the expectation that we should be able to explain exactly where information originates. We are understandably reassured by explanations. They help us organize experience, and can distinguish what is reliable from what is not. But there should also be room for a certain intellectual generosity toward experiences that remain difficult to explain.

Not every intuition is accurate or meaningful, just as not everything that feels mysterious proves to be so. Equally, dismissing experiences simply because we cannot yet explain them does little to advance what we claim to value: growth, enrichment, and insight.

There is a great deal to learn from remaining curious about what we perceive, and how we perceive it. One of the most useful things we can do with something we think we know is to hold it lightly enough that we can continue to see.

 Discover Consciousness and Somatic Exploration

Further Reading

1. Fellnhofer, K. (2022). Measuring and Enhancing Intuition. Nature Reviews Psychology.
A short scientific discussion of nonconscious information processing and the experimental study of intuition.

Read article

2. Kotler, S., et al. (2025). Pathfinding: A Neurodynamical Account of Intuition. Communications Biology.
A theoretical account of intuition incorporating experience, predictive processing, and neural dynamics.

Read article

3. Wahbeh, H., Fry, N., & Speirn, P. (2022). The Noetic Signature Inventory: Development, Exploration, and Initial Validation. Frontiers in Psychology.
A study developing a measure of reported noetic experiences, including direct knowing, imagery, and embodied sensation.

Read full study

 

 

 

Next
Next

When the Body Enters Another Story